Conditional probability : what is $mathbb P(F)$ for $F:$“ power supply fluctuate”.












0












$begingroup$


Here's the statement:




Quality control in a factory detects that 8% of the produced items are class $B$ quality only (i.e. not flawless). With a probability of 4% the production line functions suboptimally due to pollution, and with 50% probability the material used has quality issues. If pollution occurs, the items are class $B$ with a probability of 10%. Technicians also find that if there are fluctuations in the power supply then there is 10% probability that the product is class $B$. Based on these data, calculate the probability that power supply fluctuates.




I really have difficulty understanding the statement. As I see the problem: Let $P$ be the event "pollution", $Q$ the event a quality defect, $F$ the event "power supply fluctuate", and $B$ the event "$B$ quality".



I see the problem as follows. (see picture below).



enter image description here



So we just have
$$x=mathbb P(F)=1-0.04-0.5=0.46?$$
But I don't use $mathbb P(B)$. So maybe it should be $$mathbb P(B)=mathbb P(P)mathbb P(Bmid P)+mathbb P(Q)mathbb P(Bmid Q)+mathbb P(F)mathbb P(Bmid F)$$
which is equivalent to $$x=frac{0.01}{0.1}=0.1,$$
could it be possible?










share|cite|improve this question











$endgroup$












  • $begingroup$
    I've posted something below. A couple of caveats: first, I made some assumptions (spelled out at the start) which you might or might not have intended. second, the computation (while logically straight forward) is arithmetically unpleasant and error prone. I advise checking it carefully, line by line.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 18:53
















0












$begingroup$


Here's the statement:




Quality control in a factory detects that 8% of the produced items are class $B$ quality only (i.e. not flawless). With a probability of 4% the production line functions suboptimally due to pollution, and with 50% probability the material used has quality issues. If pollution occurs, the items are class $B$ with a probability of 10%. Technicians also find that if there are fluctuations in the power supply then there is 10% probability that the product is class $B$. Based on these data, calculate the probability that power supply fluctuates.




I really have difficulty understanding the statement. As I see the problem: Let $P$ be the event "pollution", $Q$ the event a quality defect, $F$ the event "power supply fluctuate", and $B$ the event "$B$ quality".



I see the problem as follows. (see picture below).



enter image description here



So we just have
$$x=mathbb P(F)=1-0.04-0.5=0.46?$$
But I don't use $mathbb P(B)$. So maybe it should be $$mathbb P(B)=mathbb P(P)mathbb P(Bmid P)+mathbb P(Q)mathbb P(Bmid Q)+mathbb P(F)mathbb P(Bmid F)$$
which is equivalent to $$x=frac{0.01}{0.1}=0.1,$$
could it be possible?










share|cite|improve this question











$endgroup$












  • $begingroup$
    I've posted something below. A couple of caveats: first, I made some assumptions (spelled out at the start) which you might or might not have intended. second, the computation (while logically straight forward) is arithmetically unpleasant and error prone. I advise checking it carefully, line by line.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 18:53














0












0








0





$begingroup$


Here's the statement:




Quality control in a factory detects that 8% of the produced items are class $B$ quality only (i.e. not flawless). With a probability of 4% the production line functions suboptimally due to pollution, and with 50% probability the material used has quality issues. If pollution occurs, the items are class $B$ with a probability of 10%. Technicians also find that if there are fluctuations in the power supply then there is 10% probability that the product is class $B$. Based on these data, calculate the probability that power supply fluctuates.




I really have difficulty understanding the statement. As I see the problem: Let $P$ be the event "pollution", $Q$ the event a quality defect, $F$ the event "power supply fluctuate", and $B$ the event "$B$ quality".



I see the problem as follows. (see picture below).



enter image description here



So we just have
$$x=mathbb P(F)=1-0.04-0.5=0.46?$$
But I don't use $mathbb P(B)$. So maybe it should be $$mathbb P(B)=mathbb P(P)mathbb P(Bmid P)+mathbb P(Q)mathbb P(Bmid Q)+mathbb P(F)mathbb P(Bmid F)$$
which is equivalent to $$x=frac{0.01}{0.1}=0.1,$$
could it be possible?










share|cite|improve this question











$endgroup$




Here's the statement:




Quality control in a factory detects that 8% of the produced items are class $B$ quality only (i.e. not flawless). With a probability of 4% the production line functions suboptimally due to pollution, and with 50% probability the material used has quality issues. If pollution occurs, the items are class $B$ with a probability of 10%. Technicians also find that if there are fluctuations in the power supply then there is 10% probability that the product is class $B$. Based on these data, calculate the probability that power supply fluctuates.




I really have difficulty understanding the statement. As I see the problem: Let $P$ be the event "pollution", $Q$ the event a quality defect, $F$ the event "power supply fluctuate", and $B$ the event "$B$ quality".



I see the problem as follows. (see picture below).



enter image description here



So we just have
$$x=mathbb P(F)=1-0.04-0.5=0.46?$$
But I don't use $mathbb P(B)$. So maybe it should be $$mathbb P(B)=mathbb P(P)mathbb P(Bmid P)+mathbb P(Q)mathbb P(Bmid Q)+mathbb P(F)mathbb P(Bmid F)$$
which is equivalent to $$x=frac{0.01}{0.1}=0.1,$$
could it be possible?







probability






share|cite|improve this question















share|cite|improve this question













share|cite|improve this question




share|cite|improve this question








edited Jan 17 at 19:39









Bernard

121k740116




121k740116










asked Jan 17 at 17:54









user623855user623855

1507




1507












  • $begingroup$
    I've posted something below. A couple of caveats: first, I made some assumptions (spelled out at the start) which you might or might not have intended. second, the computation (while logically straight forward) is arithmetically unpleasant and error prone. I advise checking it carefully, line by line.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 18:53


















  • $begingroup$
    I've posted something below. A couple of caveats: first, I made some assumptions (spelled out at the start) which you might or might not have intended. second, the computation (while logically straight forward) is arithmetically unpleasant and error prone. I advise checking it carefully, line by line.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 18:53
















$begingroup$
I've posted something below. A couple of caveats: first, I made some assumptions (spelled out at the start) which you might or might not have intended. second, the computation (while logically straight forward) is arithmetically unpleasant and error prone. I advise checking it carefully, line by line.
$endgroup$
– lulu
Jan 17 at 18:53




$begingroup$
I've posted something below. A couple of caveats: first, I made some assumptions (spelled out at the start) which you might or might not have intended. second, the computation (while logically straight forward) is arithmetically unpleasant and error prone. I advise checking it carefully, line by line.
$endgroup$
– lulu
Jan 17 at 18:53










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















1












$begingroup$

I'll assume that the external factors (pollution, low quality, fluctuations) occur independently. I'll also assume that these are all the external factors. That is to say, if we find a Class $B$ item then we know that at least one of those external factors was present. Let $Phi$ denote the desired answer (the probability that fluctuations occur).



Let's use $Phi$ to compute the probability that an item isn't in Class $B$. Since we know that to be $.92$ we can then solve for $Phi$. We'll denote the three externals by $P,LQ, F$ and for any of those externals we let $X^c$ denote their complement. We'll go type by type.



Type $(P^c,LQ^c,F^c)$. The probability of this state occurring is $.96times .5times (1-Phi)$ and, of course, no item of this type is in Class $B$.



Type $(P^c,LQ^c,F)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is in Class $B$ with probability $.1$, hence it is not in class $B$ with probability $.9$



Type $(P^c,LQ,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times (1-Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.9$



Type $(P,LQ^c,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times (1- Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5$



Type $(P^c,LQ,F)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.9times .9=.81$



Type $(P,LQ^c,F)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9=.45$



Type $(P,LQ,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times (1-Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9=.45$



Type $(P,LQ,F)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9times .9=.405$



Thus we get the (somewhat unpleasant) linear equation:



$$.48times (1-Phi)times 1+ .48times Phitimes .9+ .48times (1-Phi)times .9+ .02times (1-Phi)times .5+ .48times Phitimes .81+cdots $$
$$cdots +.02times Phitimes .45 +.02times (1- Phi)times .45+ .02times Phitimes .405=.92$$



And if no errors have been made (a big if, I grant) this comes to $$Phi=frac {110}{931}approx .11815$$



Note: the above is badly error prone so I strongly advise checking each stage carefully.



A simpler version: Let's only consider the three events $E_P,E_{LQ},E_F$ where, for an external variable $X$, $E_X$ denotes the event "$X$ is present and causes the item to be in Class $B$." Then we easily compute $$P(E_P)=.04times .5=.02quad P(E_{LQ})=.5times .1=.05quad P(E_F)=Phitimes .1$$ Then the probability that an item is not in class $B$ is $$.92=(1-.02)(1-.05)(1-.1times Phi)$$



Which again implies $$Phi=boxed {frac {110}{931}}$$






share|cite|improve this answer











$endgroup$













  • $begingroup$
    Thank you for your answer. You have used $Phi$ twice : for the fluctuation and for not be in $B$... is it a mistake ? Also, I don't really understand why my second method is not working, could you give me a reason ? (except that it's not working ^^)
    $endgroup$
    – user623855
    Jan 17 at 19:16










  • $begingroup$
    I only use $Phi$ to denote the fluctuation probability. Assuming independence, I just use $Phi$ to get the known probability, $.92$, that a random item is not in Class $B$. I couldn't follow your method, I'll look again.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:20










  • $begingroup$
    Sorry, I don't get it, you mean $Phi=mathbb P(Fmid B^c)$ ?
    $endgroup$
    – user623855
    Jan 17 at 19:22










  • $begingroup$
    Ok, the problem with your second method is that you don't address overlap between the external factors. If you assume that the factors are mutually exclusive you can find a simple solution along your lines, but that assumption seems badly unrealistic.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:23










  • $begingroup$
    $Phi$ is the probability that fluctuations occur. It says nothing about Class $B$.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:23











Your Answer





StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
});
});
}, "mathjax-editing");

StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "69"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});

function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: true,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: 10,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});


}
});














draft saved

draft discarded


















StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3077292%2fconditional-probability-what-is-mathbb-pf-for-f-power-supply-fluctuat%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown

























1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes








1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









1












$begingroup$

I'll assume that the external factors (pollution, low quality, fluctuations) occur independently. I'll also assume that these are all the external factors. That is to say, if we find a Class $B$ item then we know that at least one of those external factors was present. Let $Phi$ denote the desired answer (the probability that fluctuations occur).



Let's use $Phi$ to compute the probability that an item isn't in Class $B$. Since we know that to be $.92$ we can then solve for $Phi$. We'll denote the three externals by $P,LQ, F$ and for any of those externals we let $X^c$ denote their complement. We'll go type by type.



Type $(P^c,LQ^c,F^c)$. The probability of this state occurring is $.96times .5times (1-Phi)$ and, of course, no item of this type is in Class $B$.



Type $(P^c,LQ^c,F)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is in Class $B$ with probability $.1$, hence it is not in class $B$ with probability $.9$



Type $(P^c,LQ,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times (1-Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.9$



Type $(P,LQ^c,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times (1- Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5$



Type $(P^c,LQ,F)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.9times .9=.81$



Type $(P,LQ^c,F)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9=.45$



Type $(P,LQ,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times (1-Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9=.45$



Type $(P,LQ,F)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9times .9=.405$



Thus we get the (somewhat unpleasant) linear equation:



$$.48times (1-Phi)times 1+ .48times Phitimes .9+ .48times (1-Phi)times .9+ .02times (1-Phi)times .5+ .48times Phitimes .81+cdots $$
$$cdots +.02times Phitimes .45 +.02times (1- Phi)times .45+ .02times Phitimes .405=.92$$



And if no errors have been made (a big if, I grant) this comes to $$Phi=frac {110}{931}approx .11815$$



Note: the above is badly error prone so I strongly advise checking each stage carefully.



A simpler version: Let's only consider the three events $E_P,E_{LQ},E_F$ where, for an external variable $X$, $E_X$ denotes the event "$X$ is present and causes the item to be in Class $B$." Then we easily compute $$P(E_P)=.04times .5=.02quad P(E_{LQ})=.5times .1=.05quad P(E_F)=Phitimes .1$$ Then the probability that an item is not in class $B$ is $$.92=(1-.02)(1-.05)(1-.1times Phi)$$



Which again implies $$Phi=boxed {frac {110}{931}}$$






share|cite|improve this answer











$endgroup$













  • $begingroup$
    Thank you for your answer. You have used $Phi$ twice : for the fluctuation and for not be in $B$... is it a mistake ? Also, I don't really understand why my second method is not working, could you give me a reason ? (except that it's not working ^^)
    $endgroup$
    – user623855
    Jan 17 at 19:16










  • $begingroup$
    I only use $Phi$ to denote the fluctuation probability. Assuming independence, I just use $Phi$ to get the known probability, $.92$, that a random item is not in Class $B$. I couldn't follow your method, I'll look again.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:20










  • $begingroup$
    Sorry, I don't get it, you mean $Phi=mathbb P(Fmid B^c)$ ?
    $endgroup$
    – user623855
    Jan 17 at 19:22










  • $begingroup$
    Ok, the problem with your second method is that you don't address overlap between the external factors. If you assume that the factors are mutually exclusive you can find a simple solution along your lines, but that assumption seems badly unrealistic.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:23










  • $begingroup$
    $Phi$ is the probability that fluctuations occur. It says nothing about Class $B$.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:23
















1












$begingroup$

I'll assume that the external factors (pollution, low quality, fluctuations) occur independently. I'll also assume that these are all the external factors. That is to say, if we find a Class $B$ item then we know that at least one of those external factors was present. Let $Phi$ denote the desired answer (the probability that fluctuations occur).



Let's use $Phi$ to compute the probability that an item isn't in Class $B$. Since we know that to be $.92$ we can then solve for $Phi$. We'll denote the three externals by $P,LQ, F$ and for any of those externals we let $X^c$ denote their complement. We'll go type by type.



Type $(P^c,LQ^c,F^c)$. The probability of this state occurring is $.96times .5times (1-Phi)$ and, of course, no item of this type is in Class $B$.



Type $(P^c,LQ^c,F)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is in Class $B$ with probability $.1$, hence it is not in class $B$ with probability $.9$



Type $(P^c,LQ,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times (1-Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.9$



Type $(P,LQ^c,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times (1- Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5$



Type $(P^c,LQ,F)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.9times .9=.81$



Type $(P,LQ^c,F)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9=.45$



Type $(P,LQ,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times (1-Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9=.45$



Type $(P,LQ,F)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9times .9=.405$



Thus we get the (somewhat unpleasant) linear equation:



$$.48times (1-Phi)times 1+ .48times Phitimes .9+ .48times (1-Phi)times .9+ .02times (1-Phi)times .5+ .48times Phitimes .81+cdots $$
$$cdots +.02times Phitimes .45 +.02times (1- Phi)times .45+ .02times Phitimes .405=.92$$



And if no errors have been made (a big if, I grant) this comes to $$Phi=frac {110}{931}approx .11815$$



Note: the above is badly error prone so I strongly advise checking each stage carefully.



A simpler version: Let's only consider the three events $E_P,E_{LQ},E_F$ where, for an external variable $X$, $E_X$ denotes the event "$X$ is present and causes the item to be in Class $B$." Then we easily compute $$P(E_P)=.04times .5=.02quad P(E_{LQ})=.5times .1=.05quad P(E_F)=Phitimes .1$$ Then the probability that an item is not in class $B$ is $$.92=(1-.02)(1-.05)(1-.1times Phi)$$



Which again implies $$Phi=boxed {frac {110}{931}}$$






share|cite|improve this answer











$endgroup$













  • $begingroup$
    Thank you for your answer. You have used $Phi$ twice : for the fluctuation and for not be in $B$... is it a mistake ? Also, I don't really understand why my second method is not working, could you give me a reason ? (except that it's not working ^^)
    $endgroup$
    – user623855
    Jan 17 at 19:16










  • $begingroup$
    I only use $Phi$ to denote the fluctuation probability. Assuming independence, I just use $Phi$ to get the known probability, $.92$, that a random item is not in Class $B$. I couldn't follow your method, I'll look again.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:20










  • $begingroup$
    Sorry, I don't get it, you mean $Phi=mathbb P(Fmid B^c)$ ?
    $endgroup$
    – user623855
    Jan 17 at 19:22










  • $begingroup$
    Ok, the problem with your second method is that you don't address overlap between the external factors. If you assume that the factors are mutually exclusive you can find a simple solution along your lines, but that assumption seems badly unrealistic.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:23










  • $begingroup$
    $Phi$ is the probability that fluctuations occur. It says nothing about Class $B$.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:23














1












1








1





$begingroup$

I'll assume that the external factors (pollution, low quality, fluctuations) occur independently. I'll also assume that these are all the external factors. That is to say, if we find a Class $B$ item then we know that at least one of those external factors was present. Let $Phi$ denote the desired answer (the probability that fluctuations occur).



Let's use $Phi$ to compute the probability that an item isn't in Class $B$. Since we know that to be $.92$ we can then solve for $Phi$. We'll denote the three externals by $P,LQ, F$ and for any of those externals we let $X^c$ denote their complement. We'll go type by type.



Type $(P^c,LQ^c,F^c)$. The probability of this state occurring is $.96times .5times (1-Phi)$ and, of course, no item of this type is in Class $B$.



Type $(P^c,LQ^c,F)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is in Class $B$ with probability $.1$, hence it is not in class $B$ with probability $.9$



Type $(P^c,LQ,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times (1-Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.9$



Type $(P,LQ^c,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times (1- Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5$



Type $(P^c,LQ,F)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.9times .9=.81$



Type $(P,LQ^c,F)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9=.45$



Type $(P,LQ,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times (1-Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9=.45$



Type $(P,LQ,F)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9times .9=.405$



Thus we get the (somewhat unpleasant) linear equation:



$$.48times (1-Phi)times 1+ .48times Phitimes .9+ .48times (1-Phi)times .9+ .02times (1-Phi)times .5+ .48times Phitimes .81+cdots $$
$$cdots +.02times Phitimes .45 +.02times (1- Phi)times .45+ .02times Phitimes .405=.92$$



And if no errors have been made (a big if, I grant) this comes to $$Phi=frac {110}{931}approx .11815$$



Note: the above is badly error prone so I strongly advise checking each stage carefully.



A simpler version: Let's only consider the three events $E_P,E_{LQ},E_F$ where, for an external variable $X$, $E_X$ denotes the event "$X$ is present and causes the item to be in Class $B$." Then we easily compute $$P(E_P)=.04times .5=.02quad P(E_{LQ})=.5times .1=.05quad P(E_F)=Phitimes .1$$ Then the probability that an item is not in class $B$ is $$.92=(1-.02)(1-.05)(1-.1times Phi)$$



Which again implies $$Phi=boxed {frac {110}{931}}$$






share|cite|improve this answer











$endgroup$



I'll assume that the external factors (pollution, low quality, fluctuations) occur independently. I'll also assume that these are all the external factors. That is to say, if we find a Class $B$ item then we know that at least one of those external factors was present. Let $Phi$ denote the desired answer (the probability that fluctuations occur).



Let's use $Phi$ to compute the probability that an item isn't in Class $B$. Since we know that to be $.92$ we can then solve for $Phi$. We'll denote the three externals by $P,LQ, F$ and for any of those externals we let $X^c$ denote their complement. We'll go type by type.



Type $(P^c,LQ^c,F^c)$. The probability of this state occurring is $.96times .5times (1-Phi)$ and, of course, no item of this type is in Class $B$.



Type $(P^c,LQ^c,F)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is in Class $B$ with probability $.1$, hence it is not in class $B$ with probability $.9$



Type $(P^c,LQ,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times (1-Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.9$



Type $(P,LQ^c,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times (1- Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5$



Type $(P^c,LQ,F)$ The probability of this state is $.96times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.9times .9=.81$



Type $(P,LQ^c,F)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9=.45$



Type $(P,LQ,F^c)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times (1-Phi)$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9=.45$



Type $(P,LQ,F)$ The probability of this state is $.04times .5times Phi$ and an item in this state is outside Class $B$ with probability $.5times .9times .9=.405$



Thus we get the (somewhat unpleasant) linear equation:



$$.48times (1-Phi)times 1+ .48times Phitimes .9+ .48times (1-Phi)times .9+ .02times (1-Phi)times .5+ .48times Phitimes .81+cdots $$
$$cdots +.02times Phitimes .45 +.02times (1- Phi)times .45+ .02times Phitimes .405=.92$$



And if no errors have been made (a big if, I grant) this comes to $$Phi=frac {110}{931}approx .11815$$



Note: the above is badly error prone so I strongly advise checking each stage carefully.



A simpler version: Let's only consider the three events $E_P,E_{LQ},E_F$ where, for an external variable $X$, $E_X$ denotes the event "$X$ is present and causes the item to be in Class $B$." Then we easily compute $$P(E_P)=.04times .5=.02quad P(E_{LQ})=.5times .1=.05quad P(E_F)=Phitimes .1$$ Then the probability that an item is not in class $B$ is $$.92=(1-.02)(1-.05)(1-.1times Phi)$$



Which again implies $$Phi=boxed {frac {110}{931}}$$







share|cite|improve this answer














share|cite|improve this answer



share|cite|improve this answer








edited Jan 17 at 20:20

























answered Jan 17 at 18:52









lulululu

41.3k24979




41.3k24979












  • $begingroup$
    Thank you for your answer. You have used $Phi$ twice : for the fluctuation and for not be in $B$... is it a mistake ? Also, I don't really understand why my second method is not working, could you give me a reason ? (except that it's not working ^^)
    $endgroup$
    – user623855
    Jan 17 at 19:16










  • $begingroup$
    I only use $Phi$ to denote the fluctuation probability. Assuming independence, I just use $Phi$ to get the known probability, $.92$, that a random item is not in Class $B$. I couldn't follow your method, I'll look again.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:20










  • $begingroup$
    Sorry, I don't get it, you mean $Phi=mathbb P(Fmid B^c)$ ?
    $endgroup$
    – user623855
    Jan 17 at 19:22










  • $begingroup$
    Ok, the problem with your second method is that you don't address overlap between the external factors. If you assume that the factors are mutually exclusive you can find a simple solution along your lines, but that assumption seems badly unrealistic.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:23










  • $begingroup$
    $Phi$ is the probability that fluctuations occur. It says nothing about Class $B$.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:23


















  • $begingroup$
    Thank you for your answer. You have used $Phi$ twice : for the fluctuation and for not be in $B$... is it a mistake ? Also, I don't really understand why my second method is not working, could you give me a reason ? (except that it's not working ^^)
    $endgroup$
    – user623855
    Jan 17 at 19:16










  • $begingroup$
    I only use $Phi$ to denote the fluctuation probability. Assuming independence, I just use $Phi$ to get the known probability, $.92$, that a random item is not in Class $B$. I couldn't follow your method, I'll look again.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:20










  • $begingroup$
    Sorry, I don't get it, you mean $Phi=mathbb P(Fmid B^c)$ ?
    $endgroup$
    – user623855
    Jan 17 at 19:22










  • $begingroup$
    Ok, the problem with your second method is that you don't address overlap between the external factors. If you assume that the factors are mutually exclusive you can find a simple solution along your lines, but that assumption seems badly unrealistic.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:23










  • $begingroup$
    $Phi$ is the probability that fluctuations occur. It says nothing about Class $B$.
    $endgroup$
    – lulu
    Jan 17 at 19:23
















$begingroup$
Thank you for your answer. You have used $Phi$ twice : for the fluctuation and for not be in $B$... is it a mistake ? Also, I don't really understand why my second method is not working, could you give me a reason ? (except that it's not working ^^)
$endgroup$
– user623855
Jan 17 at 19:16




$begingroup$
Thank you for your answer. You have used $Phi$ twice : for the fluctuation and for not be in $B$... is it a mistake ? Also, I don't really understand why my second method is not working, could you give me a reason ? (except that it's not working ^^)
$endgroup$
– user623855
Jan 17 at 19:16












$begingroup$
I only use $Phi$ to denote the fluctuation probability. Assuming independence, I just use $Phi$ to get the known probability, $.92$, that a random item is not in Class $B$. I couldn't follow your method, I'll look again.
$endgroup$
– lulu
Jan 17 at 19:20




$begingroup$
I only use $Phi$ to denote the fluctuation probability. Assuming independence, I just use $Phi$ to get the known probability, $.92$, that a random item is not in Class $B$. I couldn't follow your method, I'll look again.
$endgroup$
– lulu
Jan 17 at 19:20












$begingroup$
Sorry, I don't get it, you mean $Phi=mathbb P(Fmid B^c)$ ?
$endgroup$
– user623855
Jan 17 at 19:22




$begingroup$
Sorry, I don't get it, you mean $Phi=mathbb P(Fmid B^c)$ ?
$endgroup$
– user623855
Jan 17 at 19:22












$begingroup$
Ok, the problem with your second method is that you don't address overlap between the external factors. If you assume that the factors are mutually exclusive you can find a simple solution along your lines, but that assumption seems badly unrealistic.
$endgroup$
– lulu
Jan 17 at 19:23




$begingroup$
Ok, the problem with your second method is that you don't address overlap between the external factors. If you assume that the factors are mutually exclusive you can find a simple solution along your lines, but that assumption seems badly unrealistic.
$endgroup$
– lulu
Jan 17 at 19:23












$begingroup$
$Phi$ is the probability that fluctuations occur. It says nothing about Class $B$.
$endgroup$
– lulu
Jan 17 at 19:23




$begingroup$
$Phi$ is the probability that fluctuations occur. It says nothing about Class $B$.
$endgroup$
– lulu
Jan 17 at 19:23


















draft saved

draft discarded




















































Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematics Stack Exchange!


  • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

But avoid



  • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

  • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




draft saved


draft discarded














StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3077292%2fconditional-probability-what-is-mathbb-pf-for-f-power-supply-fluctuat%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown





















































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown

































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown







Popular posts from this blog

Mario Kart Wii

What does “Dominus providebit” mean?

Antonio Litta Visconti Arese