How do you tell which noun an adjective is modifying?












2















In the refrain or chorus of the Russian national anthem, there is a line that goes: "Славься, Отечество наше свободное."



Word for word, that might read (to me, at least), "Glory to the fatherland, our freedom."



That doesn't quite make sense, even to me. A better translation might be, "Glory to our fatherland, [which is] free."



My confusion arises from the fact that in English, adjectives (almost) always precede nouns. Is this true in Russian or not? That is, can the noun Отечество be followed by one or two adjectives instead of being preceded by them? Is it true that it's the word forms and declensions and not word order that determines the function of each word in a sentence?










share|improve this question

























  • In Russian, words order in a sentence can be anything. Some orders may feel more natural than the others, but you can almost never be technically wrong re-arranging the words. The great flexibility comes at a great price, though: you have to know all those inflection suffixes.

    – Headcrab
    Jan 11 at 4:05
















2















In the refrain or chorus of the Russian national anthem, there is a line that goes: "Славься, Отечество наше свободное."



Word for word, that might read (to me, at least), "Glory to the fatherland, our freedom."



That doesn't quite make sense, even to me. A better translation might be, "Glory to our fatherland, [which is] free."



My confusion arises from the fact that in English, adjectives (almost) always precede nouns. Is this true in Russian or not? That is, can the noun Отечество be followed by one or two adjectives instead of being preceded by them? Is it true that it's the word forms and declensions and not word order that determines the function of each word in a sentence?










share|improve this question

























  • In Russian, words order in a sentence can be anything. Some orders may feel more natural than the others, but you can almost never be technically wrong re-arranging the words. The great flexibility comes at a great price, though: you have to know all those inflection suffixes.

    – Headcrab
    Jan 11 at 4:05














2












2








2








In the refrain or chorus of the Russian national anthem, there is a line that goes: "Славься, Отечество наше свободное."



Word for word, that might read (to me, at least), "Glory to the fatherland, our freedom."



That doesn't quite make sense, even to me. A better translation might be, "Glory to our fatherland, [which is] free."



My confusion arises from the fact that in English, adjectives (almost) always precede nouns. Is this true in Russian or not? That is, can the noun Отечество be followed by one or two adjectives instead of being preceded by them? Is it true that it's the word forms and declensions and not word order that determines the function of each word in a sentence?










share|improve this question
















In the refrain or chorus of the Russian national anthem, there is a line that goes: "Славься, Отечество наше свободное."



Word for word, that might read (to me, at least), "Glory to the fatherland, our freedom."



That doesn't quite make sense, even to me. A better translation might be, "Glory to our fatherland, [which is] free."



My confusion arises from the fact that in English, adjectives (almost) always precede nouns. Is this true in Russian or not? That is, can the noun Отечество be followed by one or two adjectives instead of being preceded by them? Is it true that it's the word forms and declensions and not word order that determines the function of each word in a sentence?







word-order






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Jan 10 at 17:48









shabunc

21.9k45197




21.9k45197










asked Jan 10 at 17:40









Tom AuTom Au

790415




790415













  • In Russian, words order in a sentence can be anything. Some orders may feel more natural than the others, but you can almost never be technically wrong re-arranging the words. The great flexibility comes at a great price, though: you have to know all those inflection suffixes.

    – Headcrab
    Jan 11 at 4:05



















  • In Russian, words order in a sentence can be anything. Some orders may feel more natural than the others, but you can almost never be technically wrong re-arranging the words. The great flexibility comes at a great price, though: you have to know all those inflection suffixes.

    – Headcrab
    Jan 11 at 4:05

















In Russian, words order in a sentence can be anything. Some orders may feel more natural than the others, but you can almost never be technically wrong re-arranging the words. The great flexibility comes at a great price, though: you have to know all those inflection suffixes.

– Headcrab
Jan 11 at 4:05





In Russian, words order in a sentence can be anything. Some orders may feel more natural than the others, but you can almost never be technically wrong re-arranging the words. The great flexibility comes at a great price, though: you have to know all those inflection suffixes.

– Headcrab
Jan 11 at 4:05










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes


















6














Your translation is incorrect, "свободное" is free, an adjective, not a noun, freedom, which is "свобода". In modern Russian the majority of adjectives indeed precedes nouns, so one will say "наше свободное отечество".



In poetry and lyrics, however, it's pretty acceptable to put adjective after noun - for the sake of rhyming and/or metrical foot.



There's also bunch of phrases where adjective comes after the noun (or at least used alongside with "normal" form pretty widely) - like вечер добрый, дубина стоеросовая etc.



Other - extremely small and quite exotic - category of adjectives that usually are put after the noun - is one that contains indeclinable adjectives of foreign origin, like "пиджаки беж". This is more of a curiosity actually.



Finally, I want stop your attention on following fact. Compare two sentences:




Вася, смелый и ловкий, стукнул медведя по носу деревянной ложкой.




and




Смелый и ловкий Вася стукнул медведя по носу деревянной ложкой.




The order in first sentence sort of emphasize the fact that Vasya is brave and deft, while in the second sentence it's rather an established fact.






share|improve this answer


























  • Стукнул по носу медведя деревянной ложкой Вася. По носу медведя стукнул Вася ложкой деревянной. Вдруг медведя деревянной стукнул ложкой смелый Вася. Etc.

    – Elena
    Jan 10 at 18:44











  • @Elena никто не спорит об относительно свободном порядке слов в русском, но прилагательное и существительное в довольно предсказуемом порядке всё-таки идут.

    – shabunc
    Jan 10 at 18:52











  • Я не спорю, я дополняю. В целом, они где-то рядом, но в устной и поэтической речи их порой разбрасывает по разным концам предложения.

    – Elena
    Jan 10 at 18:55











  • Кроме того, прилагательное может быть вообще в следующем предложении.

    – Elena
    Jan 13 at 11:28



















3














It is easy. )))))



Just bear in mind, that a noun and its adjective always agree in gender, number and case.




Отечество - neuter, singular, Nominative. свободное - neuter,
singular, Nominative.




Adjectives have endings -ый/ий(m), -ая/яя(f), -ое/ее(n), -ие/ые(pl) in the Nominative case.



They are not nouns, except for several nouns derived from adjectives and used absolutely, like учительская (teachers' room in a school), ординаторская (doctors' room in a hospital), outdated мертвецкая (a room for corpses in a hospital), and several others, they do not change their gender, and they are found in dictionaries as nouns. Earlier they had a noun (for the three named words it was комната).



Flective languages have a relatively free word order, as inversion (when you verb nouns, etc.) is hardly possible with them. We have endings, which define: a part of speech, gender, number, case, person, plurality, tense. Prefices and endings define perfective verbs. One word contains enough grammatical information.



Meanwhile, such languages as English, with neither cases nor genders, have no other possibility to retain logic in a sentence but putting words in a strict order. You recognize relations between words by their order, and we know that from endings.






share|improve this answer

























    Your Answer








    StackExchange.ready(function() {
    var channelOptions = {
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "451"
    };
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
    createEditor();
    });
    }
    else {
    createEditor();
    }
    });

    function createEditor() {
    StackExchange.prepareEditor({
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
    convertImagesToLinks: false,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: null,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader: {
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    },
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    });


    }
    });














    draft saved

    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function () {
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frussian.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f17937%2fhow-do-you-tell-which-noun-an-adjective-is-modifying%23new-answer', 'question_page');
    }
    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes








    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    6














    Your translation is incorrect, "свободное" is free, an adjective, not a noun, freedom, which is "свобода". In modern Russian the majority of adjectives indeed precedes nouns, so one will say "наше свободное отечество".



    In poetry and lyrics, however, it's pretty acceptable to put adjective after noun - for the sake of rhyming and/or metrical foot.



    There's also bunch of phrases where adjective comes after the noun (or at least used alongside with "normal" form pretty widely) - like вечер добрый, дубина стоеросовая etc.



    Other - extremely small and quite exotic - category of adjectives that usually are put after the noun - is one that contains indeclinable adjectives of foreign origin, like "пиджаки беж". This is more of a curiosity actually.



    Finally, I want stop your attention on following fact. Compare two sentences:




    Вася, смелый и ловкий, стукнул медведя по носу деревянной ложкой.




    and




    Смелый и ловкий Вася стукнул медведя по носу деревянной ложкой.




    The order in first sentence sort of emphasize the fact that Vasya is brave and deft, while in the second sentence it's rather an established fact.






    share|improve this answer


























    • Стукнул по носу медведя деревянной ложкой Вася. По носу медведя стукнул Вася ложкой деревянной. Вдруг медведя деревянной стукнул ложкой смелый Вася. Etc.

      – Elena
      Jan 10 at 18:44











    • @Elena никто не спорит об относительно свободном порядке слов в русском, но прилагательное и существительное в довольно предсказуемом порядке всё-таки идут.

      – shabunc
      Jan 10 at 18:52











    • Я не спорю, я дополняю. В целом, они где-то рядом, но в устной и поэтической речи их порой разбрасывает по разным концам предложения.

      – Elena
      Jan 10 at 18:55











    • Кроме того, прилагательное может быть вообще в следующем предложении.

      – Elena
      Jan 13 at 11:28
















    6














    Your translation is incorrect, "свободное" is free, an adjective, not a noun, freedom, which is "свобода". In modern Russian the majority of adjectives indeed precedes nouns, so one will say "наше свободное отечество".



    In poetry and lyrics, however, it's pretty acceptable to put adjective after noun - for the sake of rhyming and/or metrical foot.



    There's also bunch of phrases where adjective comes after the noun (or at least used alongside with "normal" form pretty widely) - like вечер добрый, дубина стоеросовая etc.



    Other - extremely small and quite exotic - category of adjectives that usually are put after the noun - is one that contains indeclinable adjectives of foreign origin, like "пиджаки беж". This is more of a curiosity actually.



    Finally, I want stop your attention on following fact. Compare two sentences:




    Вася, смелый и ловкий, стукнул медведя по носу деревянной ложкой.




    and




    Смелый и ловкий Вася стукнул медведя по носу деревянной ложкой.




    The order in first sentence sort of emphasize the fact that Vasya is brave and deft, while in the second sentence it's rather an established fact.






    share|improve this answer


























    • Стукнул по носу медведя деревянной ложкой Вася. По носу медведя стукнул Вася ложкой деревянной. Вдруг медведя деревянной стукнул ложкой смелый Вася. Etc.

      – Elena
      Jan 10 at 18:44











    • @Elena никто не спорит об относительно свободном порядке слов в русском, но прилагательное и существительное в довольно предсказуемом порядке всё-таки идут.

      – shabunc
      Jan 10 at 18:52











    • Я не спорю, я дополняю. В целом, они где-то рядом, но в устной и поэтической речи их порой разбрасывает по разным концам предложения.

      – Elena
      Jan 10 at 18:55











    • Кроме того, прилагательное может быть вообще в следующем предложении.

      – Elena
      Jan 13 at 11:28














    6












    6








    6







    Your translation is incorrect, "свободное" is free, an adjective, not a noun, freedom, which is "свобода". In modern Russian the majority of adjectives indeed precedes nouns, so one will say "наше свободное отечество".



    In poetry and lyrics, however, it's pretty acceptable to put adjective after noun - for the sake of rhyming and/or metrical foot.



    There's also bunch of phrases where adjective comes after the noun (or at least used alongside with "normal" form pretty widely) - like вечер добрый, дубина стоеросовая etc.



    Other - extremely small and quite exotic - category of adjectives that usually are put after the noun - is one that contains indeclinable adjectives of foreign origin, like "пиджаки беж". This is more of a curiosity actually.



    Finally, I want stop your attention on following fact. Compare two sentences:




    Вася, смелый и ловкий, стукнул медведя по носу деревянной ложкой.




    and




    Смелый и ловкий Вася стукнул медведя по носу деревянной ложкой.




    The order in first sentence sort of emphasize the fact that Vasya is brave and deft, while in the second sentence it's rather an established fact.






    share|improve this answer















    Your translation is incorrect, "свободное" is free, an adjective, not a noun, freedom, which is "свобода". In modern Russian the majority of adjectives indeed precedes nouns, so one will say "наше свободное отечество".



    In poetry and lyrics, however, it's pretty acceptable to put adjective after noun - for the sake of rhyming and/or metrical foot.



    There's also bunch of phrases where adjective comes after the noun (or at least used alongside with "normal" form pretty widely) - like вечер добрый, дубина стоеросовая etc.



    Other - extremely small and quite exotic - category of adjectives that usually are put after the noun - is one that contains indeclinable adjectives of foreign origin, like "пиджаки беж". This is more of a curiosity actually.



    Finally, I want stop your attention on following fact. Compare two sentences:




    Вася, смелый и ловкий, стукнул медведя по носу деревянной ложкой.




    and




    Смелый и ловкий Вася стукнул медведя по носу деревянной ложкой.




    The order in first sentence sort of emphasize the fact that Vasya is brave and deft, while in the second sentence it's rather an established fact.







    share|improve this answer














    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer








    edited Jan 10 at 18:11

























    answered Jan 10 at 17:47









    shabuncshabunc

    21.9k45197




    21.9k45197













    • Стукнул по носу медведя деревянной ложкой Вася. По носу медведя стукнул Вася ложкой деревянной. Вдруг медведя деревянной стукнул ложкой смелый Вася. Etc.

      – Elena
      Jan 10 at 18:44











    • @Elena никто не спорит об относительно свободном порядке слов в русском, но прилагательное и существительное в довольно предсказуемом порядке всё-таки идут.

      – shabunc
      Jan 10 at 18:52











    • Я не спорю, я дополняю. В целом, они где-то рядом, но в устной и поэтической речи их порой разбрасывает по разным концам предложения.

      – Elena
      Jan 10 at 18:55











    • Кроме того, прилагательное может быть вообще в следующем предложении.

      – Elena
      Jan 13 at 11:28



















    • Стукнул по носу медведя деревянной ложкой Вася. По носу медведя стукнул Вася ложкой деревянной. Вдруг медведя деревянной стукнул ложкой смелый Вася. Etc.

      – Elena
      Jan 10 at 18:44











    • @Elena никто не спорит об относительно свободном порядке слов в русском, но прилагательное и существительное в довольно предсказуемом порядке всё-таки идут.

      – shabunc
      Jan 10 at 18:52











    • Я не спорю, я дополняю. В целом, они где-то рядом, но в устной и поэтической речи их порой разбрасывает по разным концам предложения.

      – Elena
      Jan 10 at 18:55











    • Кроме того, прилагательное может быть вообще в следующем предложении.

      – Elena
      Jan 13 at 11:28

















    Стукнул по носу медведя деревянной ложкой Вася. По носу медведя стукнул Вася ложкой деревянной. Вдруг медведя деревянной стукнул ложкой смелый Вася. Etc.

    – Elena
    Jan 10 at 18:44





    Стукнул по носу медведя деревянной ложкой Вася. По носу медведя стукнул Вася ложкой деревянной. Вдруг медведя деревянной стукнул ложкой смелый Вася. Etc.

    – Elena
    Jan 10 at 18:44













    @Elena никто не спорит об относительно свободном порядке слов в русском, но прилагательное и существительное в довольно предсказуемом порядке всё-таки идут.

    – shabunc
    Jan 10 at 18:52





    @Elena никто не спорит об относительно свободном порядке слов в русском, но прилагательное и существительное в довольно предсказуемом порядке всё-таки идут.

    – shabunc
    Jan 10 at 18:52













    Я не спорю, я дополняю. В целом, они где-то рядом, но в устной и поэтической речи их порой разбрасывает по разным концам предложения.

    – Elena
    Jan 10 at 18:55





    Я не спорю, я дополняю. В целом, они где-то рядом, но в устной и поэтической речи их порой разбрасывает по разным концам предложения.

    – Elena
    Jan 10 at 18:55













    Кроме того, прилагательное может быть вообще в следующем предложении.

    – Elena
    Jan 13 at 11:28





    Кроме того, прилагательное может быть вообще в следующем предложении.

    – Elena
    Jan 13 at 11:28











    3














    It is easy. )))))



    Just bear in mind, that a noun and its adjective always agree in gender, number and case.




    Отечество - neuter, singular, Nominative. свободное - neuter,
    singular, Nominative.




    Adjectives have endings -ый/ий(m), -ая/яя(f), -ое/ее(n), -ие/ые(pl) in the Nominative case.



    They are not nouns, except for several nouns derived from adjectives and used absolutely, like учительская (teachers' room in a school), ординаторская (doctors' room in a hospital), outdated мертвецкая (a room for corpses in a hospital), and several others, they do not change their gender, and they are found in dictionaries as nouns. Earlier they had a noun (for the three named words it was комната).



    Flective languages have a relatively free word order, as inversion (when you verb nouns, etc.) is hardly possible with them. We have endings, which define: a part of speech, gender, number, case, person, plurality, tense. Prefices and endings define perfective verbs. One word contains enough grammatical information.



    Meanwhile, such languages as English, with neither cases nor genders, have no other possibility to retain logic in a sentence but putting words in a strict order. You recognize relations between words by their order, and we know that from endings.






    share|improve this answer






























      3














      It is easy. )))))



      Just bear in mind, that a noun and its adjective always agree in gender, number and case.




      Отечество - neuter, singular, Nominative. свободное - neuter,
      singular, Nominative.




      Adjectives have endings -ый/ий(m), -ая/яя(f), -ое/ее(n), -ие/ые(pl) in the Nominative case.



      They are not nouns, except for several nouns derived from adjectives and used absolutely, like учительская (teachers' room in a school), ординаторская (doctors' room in a hospital), outdated мертвецкая (a room for corpses in a hospital), and several others, they do not change their gender, and they are found in dictionaries as nouns. Earlier they had a noun (for the three named words it was комната).



      Flective languages have a relatively free word order, as inversion (when you verb nouns, etc.) is hardly possible with them. We have endings, which define: a part of speech, gender, number, case, person, plurality, tense. Prefices and endings define perfective verbs. One word contains enough grammatical information.



      Meanwhile, such languages as English, with neither cases nor genders, have no other possibility to retain logic in a sentence but putting words in a strict order. You recognize relations between words by their order, and we know that from endings.






      share|improve this answer




























        3












        3








        3







        It is easy. )))))



        Just bear in mind, that a noun and its adjective always agree in gender, number and case.




        Отечество - neuter, singular, Nominative. свободное - neuter,
        singular, Nominative.




        Adjectives have endings -ый/ий(m), -ая/яя(f), -ое/ее(n), -ие/ые(pl) in the Nominative case.



        They are not nouns, except for several nouns derived from adjectives and used absolutely, like учительская (teachers' room in a school), ординаторская (doctors' room in a hospital), outdated мертвецкая (a room for corpses in a hospital), and several others, they do not change their gender, and they are found in dictionaries as nouns. Earlier they had a noun (for the three named words it was комната).



        Flective languages have a relatively free word order, as inversion (when you verb nouns, etc.) is hardly possible with them. We have endings, which define: a part of speech, gender, number, case, person, plurality, tense. Prefices and endings define perfective verbs. One word contains enough grammatical information.



        Meanwhile, such languages as English, with neither cases nor genders, have no other possibility to retain logic in a sentence but putting words in a strict order. You recognize relations between words by their order, and we know that from endings.






        share|improve this answer















        It is easy. )))))



        Just bear in mind, that a noun and its adjective always agree in gender, number and case.




        Отечество - neuter, singular, Nominative. свободное - neuter,
        singular, Nominative.




        Adjectives have endings -ый/ий(m), -ая/яя(f), -ое/ее(n), -ие/ые(pl) in the Nominative case.



        They are not nouns, except for several nouns derived from adjectives and used absolutely, like учительская (teachers' room in a school), ординаторская (doctors' room in a hospital), outdated мертвецкая (a room for corpses in a hospital), and several others, they do not change their gender, and they are found in dictionaries as nouns. Earlier they had a noun (for the three named words it was комната).



        Flective languages have a relatively free word order, as inversion (when you verb nouns, etc.) is hardly possible with them. We have endings, which define: a part of speech, gender, number, case, person, plurality, tense. Prefices and endings define perfective verbs. One word contains enough grammatical information.



        Meanwhile, such languages as English, with neither cases nor genders, have no other possibility to retain logic in a sentence but putting words in a strict order. You recognize relations between words by their order, and we know that from endings.







        share|improve this answer














        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer








        edited Jan 10 at 19:41

























        answered Jan 10 at 18:42









        ElenaElena

        2,153210




        2,153210






























            draft saved

            draft discarded




















































            Thanks for contributing an answer to Russian Language Stack Exchange!


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frussian.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f17937%2fhow-do-you-tell-which-noun-an-adjective-is-modifying%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            Mario Kart Wii

            The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth/Afterbirth

            What does “Dominus providebit” mean?